An open letter by Gerd Buurmann to Pink Floyd

Dear Pink Floyd,

There are nearly 1,694,000 Muslims living peacefully with Jews in Israel. They are the neighbors, colleagues, teachers, lawyers, judges, deputies, police officers, firefighters, soldiers, cooks, sexual partners and much, much more of the Jewish population. They laugh, live, eat, cry and fight together. They live together, not only because they want to live together, but because they have to live together. They share the same country. They are connected in fidelity with the trees, rivers, mountains, seas, lakes, towns, villages and deserts of their homeland which they often include in their prayers. They are one family! Some are distant relatives, others trusted friends. 1,694,000 Muslims are affirmative in their attitudes towards Jews and reach out their hands in peace.

However, those 1,694,000 Muslims are discriminated against by the global campaign of hatred called BDS! The name BDS stands for „Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions“. BDS opposes Israel as a whole and is against Israeli culture. All 1,694,000 Muslims who are living in peace, neighborliness, equality, tolerance and respect with Jews are Israeli citizens and thus the target of BDS discrimination. The campaign encourages boycotting and punishing Muslims, as well as to end any kind of support for those Israeli Muslims.

BDS demands that Muslims who live peacefully with Jews be treated as Jews.

There shall be no form of recognition of Israel! The Hamas Deputy Minister of Religious Endowments, Abdallah Jarbu, declared on February 28, 2010:

“Jews are foreign bacteria –microbes unparalleled in the world. (…) I condemn whoever believes in normalizing relations with them, whoever supports sitting down with them, and whoever believes that they are human beings. They are not human beings.“

BDS is not directed against this man and his party. BDS is also not against Wiam Wahhab and his party. Wahab, a former Lebanese minister, said on Al-Jadid / New TV (July 4, 2010) that he supported Brazil for their soccer, but Germany politically „because they hate the Jews and they burned them“.

Lebanon is one of the countries which have imposed a travel ban against me, Gerd Buurmann, just because I dared to visit the land of Israel. Besides Lebanon, Syria, Kuwait, Yemen, Libya, Saudi Arabia and Iran reserve the right to not let people into their countries if they are Jews or visited Israel. Many of these countries express pride in having expelled all Jews from their countries. They are proud of genocide. These countries also have pride in pursuing homosexuals. Homosexuals are executed regularly in Iran, Yemen, Saudi Arabia and in Gaza. In Saudi Arabia, women are not permitted to drive cars and leave home without the permission of a man. These countries operate the worst kinds of apartheid. BDS isn’t directed against any of these countries! They are the ones which promote the BDS movement. But why?

BDS is directed against a country which decided to equip public hospitals with prayer rooms for all religions, after a Muslim had successfully appealed to the Supreme Judicial Court because he had to pray outdoors in front of a hospital in Tel Aviv. There are no prayer rooms in hospitals in the Gaza Strip, in Algeria, Saudi Arabia, Jordan and in Libya for Jews, much less even residence permits for them. In these regions, it is forbidden to be a Jew. Those places are all „Jew-free“!

BDS is directed against the country in which the then 19-year-old Arab woman from the northern port city of Akko, Lina Mahul, won first place in the Israeli edition of „The Voice“. BDS is not directed against the country in which Mohammed Assaf won the Arabic version of DSDS (Arab Idol) with a song which tells of the destruction of Israel.

Some time ago in Israeli television, a hidden camera revealed how the people of Israel responded to discrimination. A gas station retailer refused to serve Arabs. TV show guests responded as follows:

BDS is directed against these people and thus against the only country in the Middle East in which 1,694,000 Muslims live securely, in a democracy which allows them to be gay or lesbian. They have the same rights as all other citizens in the country, regardless of their gender and skin color. Every fifth Israeli is a Muslim and according to a representative survey by the Harvard Kennedy School, 77 percent of them said they prefer to live in Israel more than any other country! There is hardly another country in the world which Muslims love more.

BDS is directed against those Muslims! Israel is the only country in the Middle East, in which the people can choose their government… and have it replaced. The Israeli government is the only democratically elected country in the Middle East in which Muslims and Arabs reside. BDS agitates against that country. Mahmoud Abbas was elected in 2005 as president of the Palestinian Authority, but his term ended on January 9, 2009. Since then, he holds no legitimacy. BDS remains silent! Jordan is a monarchy with Islam as the state religion and Sharia law. All non-Muslim Palestinians in Jordan are second-class citizens. BDS is silent! In Syria, all Palestinians have been disenfranchised and are locked up in refugee camps. In January 2014, the Syrian army encircled Palestinians in a camp and let them starve. BDS is silent!

BDS is aimed exclusively against Israel and thus against all Israeli Muslims living in peace with Jews. Unfortunately, this campaign has many prominent supporters such as you. This shows that anti-Semitism is an over thousand year old disease. It’s still very contagious and even intelligence offers no certain immunity against infection. Even Jews are infected by it.

Jew-hatred is a special form of discrimination and can be expressed in this simple formula: „A Jew-hater criticizes Jews for things that non-Jews are not criticized for.“ This is precisely the hatred of the BDS movement

BDS is silent on all barbaric inhumanity in the world, but criticizes Israel because the country is not perfect. BDS denies the right for the existence of Jews if they are not perfect. Jews must be superhuman in order to retain a right of existence. For all others it’s OK to just be human. An Israeli politician is already demonized when he’s not a saint. An Arab politician can be a saint for just not being a devil. This is the century old campaign against Jews and BDS is a modern child of that ancient hatred.

This hatred spends billions to find Jews who are not perfect and call out: Look, the Jews! Countless journalists, correspondents, European and American organizations are in Israel for the sole purpose of making documentaries and writing stories that show that Jews are not perfect. These images, films and stories are produced in short intervals by government-sponsored media from CNN to the BBC in order to perpetuate the idea that Israel is the greatest threat to world peace.

Israel will stay Israel! Israel is the only country that despite a nearly seventy-year-long war, whereby adversaries aim for its complete destruction, has retained all basic principles of a democratic society. This is unique in history. Although Israel is not perfect, there is no other country which does so well in the face of such animosity and hate.

Why do you support this movement?

Please don’t tell me the mistakes Israel has made. I’m informed enough. Please explain why you are not only more critical of Jews, but very tough in your assessment. Why do you support an organization that boycotts, sanctions and punishes Jews if they are not perfect, and are silent on the barbarous inhumanity of those who want to annihilate the Jews?

All the best,
Gerd Buurmann (Cologne, Germany)

(Translation: William Wires)

Dieser Beitrag wurde unter In English veröffentlicht. Setze ein Lesezeichen auf den Permalink.

7 Antworten zu An open letter by Gerd Buurmann to Pink Floyd

  1. Eliyah schreibt:

    Roger Waters ist ein dummer Antisemit. Nicht erst seit gestern.

  2. Ulf Renner schreibt:

    Lieber Gerd Buurmann, es ist ja gut und wichtig, daß Sie hier allerlei offene Briefe veröffentlichen, aber gehen die auch direkt an die jeweiligen Empfänger (im vorliegenden Fall also an die PF-Musiker)? Die Adressaten dürften ja wohl kaum zu den Lesern Ihres Blogs gehören. Wenn sie die Schreiben nicht auch direkt erhalten, dann bekommen sie höchstwahrscheinlich nichts davon mit (es sei denn, jemand weist sie darauf hin). Das ist sicher mit ein Grund dafür, daß die offenen Briefe zumeist ohne Reaktion der Angesprochenen bleiben.

  3. ceterum censeo schreibt:

    Also ich werde mir ihre Musik, oder auch dem Wagnern seine, weiterhin anhören. Man kann ein phantastischer Schauspieler, Schriftsteller, Musiker, Wissenschaftler oder Komponist, und gleichzeitig blöde sein.

    • Ulf Renner schreibt:

      Stimmt in der Tendenz, aber Hass gegen Juden und Feindschaft zu Israel sind leider keine Folgen von Blödheit. BDS und deren Unterstützer sind nicht dumm, sie agieren im Gegenteil durchdacht, raffiniert und vielfach mit Erfolg. Das ist nicht zu unterschätzen. Was hier wirkt, ist die Erkenntnis und Devise von Goebbels (ebenfalls kein Dummer): „Tausendmal wiederholte Lügen werden zur Wahrheit!“

    • Anonymous schreibt:

      So ist es, leider. Die beste Punkband heute sind die Sleaford Mods, deren Frontmann ein hundertprozentiger Fan vom pro-islamischen, anti-israelischen Labour-Chef Jeremy Corbyn ist. Traurig aber wahr.

  4. Sophist X schreibt:

    These burnt out junkies won’t unterstand a single word you wrote.

    I know something better: BPFF (Boycott Pink Fucking Floyd).
    #BoycottPinkFuckingFloyd

Seid gut zueinander!

Trage deine Daten unten ein oder klicke ein Icon um dich einzuloggen:

WordPress.com-Logo

Du kommentierst mit Deinem WordPress.com-Konto. Abmelden / Ändern )

Twitter-Bild

Du kommentierst mit Deinem Twitter-Konto. Abmelden / Ändern )

Facebook-Foto

Du kommentierst mit Deinem Facebook-Konto. Abmelden / Ändern )

Google+ Foto

Du kommentierst mit Deinem Google+-Konto. Abmelden / Ändern )

Verbinde mit %s